Review · NEW YORK CITY

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience!

★ 5.0 · 69 reviews 3 hours (approx.) From $38 Operated by Telltale Tours · Bookable on Viator
Book on Viator →

Secrets work best after dark. For $38, this three-hour New York tour pairs Prohibition stories with visits to at least three bars, pubs, and modern speakeasies. I like the small group size, capped at 15, and the free admission with express entry, a real help at popular Midtown bars.

I also like the mix of stops: Times Square, Broadway country, rooftop skyline views, and Hell’s Kitchen immigrant history. The main caution is simple: drinks and food cost extra, and not every stop may feel like a truly secret speakeasy.

Key points to know before you book

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Key points to know before you book

  • Three very different venues: Expect a bar hop that can include craft cocktails, live music, Broadway-linked entertainment, and modern speakeasy-style rooms.
  • A strong guide can make the night: Walter, Ariel, Ryan, Arielle, Kate, Emma, and others have earned praise for storytelling, humor, and local drink advice.
  • Rooftop views add variety: You may see the Empire State Building up close and take in a broad Manhattan skyline between bar visits.
  • The $38 covers entry, not drinks: Cocktails have averaged about $15 in one reported experience, so budget for several purchases.
  • Dress matters: Wear upscale casual clothing. Sportswear and ripped clothes are not permitted.
  • Plan for easy city walking: The route begins at 825 8th Avenue and ends in Hell’s Kitchen after roughly three hours.

A Prohibition night in the middle of Midtown

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - A Prohibition night in the middle of Midtown

New York’s Prohibition story is often told through gangsters, hidden doors, and cocktails served behind ordinary storefronts. This experience adds another layer by setting the story among Times Square, Broadway, and Hell’s Kitchen, where the city’s old immigrant communities helped shape nightlife and neighborhood politics.

You meet at 825 8th Avenue, New York, New York 10019. From there, a licensed host leads the group on foot through Midtown and toward Hell’s Kitchen. The route is not a museum tour with long lectures. It is a moving evening of short walks, city views, historical commentary, and stops for drinks.

That format works well for me because New York history makes more sense when you are standing in the neighborhoods connected to it. You get the broad story of Prohibition, then see how bars, entertainment, immigrant communities, and organized crime affected one another.

The tour is offered in English and lasts about three hours. It is best suited to adults who enjoy cocktails, social conversation, and a bit of theatrical atmosphere. The group limit of 15 is small enough for the host to keep people together without turning the evening into a private tour.

A few more history tours around New York City worth a look

Times Square sets the scene

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Times Square sets the scene

The first part takes you through historic Times Square. Today, the area is famous for giant screens, theaters, and crowds, but it also works as an introduction to New York’s entertainment culture and the city’s long relationship with nightlife.

Do not expect a lengthy architectural walk here. The focus is the Prohibition-era story and the role of entertainment districts in shaping the city after dark. Your guide may use the surrounding theaters and streets to explain how the city’s social life continued even when alcohol sales were illegal.

This opening also helps you settle into the group. A good host gives you a sense of what the night will be like, and several guides have been praised for making introductions easy and keeping the pace moving. Ryan, Ariel, Arielle, and Walter have each been singled out for humor, energy, and clear storytelling.

Times Square is also where practical footwear matters. You will be walking through Midtown streets, crossing busy areas, and moving between venues. The tour calls for a moderate level of fitness, though the walking is described as manageable rather than strenuous.

Rooftop views with the Empire State Building nearby

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Rooftop views with the Empire State Building nearby

One stop offers panoramic views of the Manhattan skyline from a rooftop lounge. The Empire State Building is a key part of the view, and seeing it up close gives the evening a welcome change of pace.

This stop is valuable because the tour is not just a sequence of dark bars. You get a chance to look outward, take in the city, and understand how tightly packed Midtown is. A rooftop also gives the group a natural pause before the next venue.

The exact drink menu and seating setup can vary, so think of this as a view-focused lounge stop rather than a guaranteed full meal. Food and drinks are available for purchase at the venues, but neither is included in the tour price.

If the weather is poor, the experience may be canceled. In that case, you are offered another date or a full refund. That weather condition is worth remembering when planning a special evening around the tour.

Broadway, restaurants, and nightlife history

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Broadway, restaurants, and nightlife history

The route also passes through the area known for Broadway shows and restaurants. This portion connects the bars to New York’s performance culture, which is one of the most enjoyable themes running through the experience.

Some reported outings included stage-set models, live music, and performances by Broadway performers. One guide even had acted at one of the venues. Those details will not necessarily appear on every departure, but they show the sort of entertainment atmosphere you may encounter.

This is one reason I would choose the tour over a standard pub crawl. You are not simply being taken from one drink to the next. The venues can have their own identity, and your guide helps explain how each place fits the evening’s theme.

At the same time, keep your expectations sensible. One account found that only the first bar felt secret or especially unusual, while the next two seemed more like regular trendy bars. The experience uses the speakeasy idea broadly, including modern venues inspired by hidden-bar culture. If you want three perfectly concealed rooms with secret passwords, this may disappoint you.

Same place, a different slice of the past:

Hell’s Kitchen and the immigrant story

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Hell’s Kitchen and the immigrant story

The final area is Hell’s Kitchen, where the tour discusses immigrant communities and the neighborhood’s role in Prohibition-era New York. The district’s Irish connections, local power struggles, and organized crime history are part of the story your guide may explain.

This is where the tour gains its strongest sense of place. You are not hearing Prohibition as a dry national law. You are hearing how it affected a neighborhood with a strong immigrant identity and a busy entertainment economy.

The tour ends in Hell’s Kitchen, New York, New York 10036. That gives you a useful place to continue your night, especially if your guide offers suggestions for nearby food or drinks. Arielle was praised for local recommendations, and other hosts have helped people choose where to eat and drink after the tour.

Because the ending is in a restaurant and bar district, I would avoid scheduling a theater ticket immediately afterward. The tour lasts about three hours, but walking time, venue entry, and the pace of the group can vary.

Three venues, three different moods

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Three venues, three different moods

The strongest part of this experience is the contrast between stops. You may visit at least three venues, and previous outings have included places with very different moods.

One location has been described as hip-hop themed. Another had elaborate stage-related displays. A third offered live music. In other cases, the venues felt like popular cocktail bars, with the group receiving express entry while other people waited outside.

That express entry can be worth a lot in Midtown. If a bar has a long line, walking in with your host saves time and removes some of the uncertainty of a busy evening. It also lets you see places you might skip if you were exploring on your own.

The tradeoff is that the word speakeasy covers several types of venue here. Some stops may have a strong hidden-bar feel. Others may simply be stylish cocktail bars with a Prohibition connection, a theatrical theme, or a tucked-away entrance.

The drinks are a major part of the fun. Craft cocktails have been praised repeatedly, and one experience put the average drink price at about $15. That is normal for high-end mixology in Midtown, but it means the true cost of the evening can rise well above the $38 tour price.

Food is also extra. Some people have had time for small bites, but the tour price does not include a meal. Eat beforehand if you need a proper dinner, or ask your guide for a nearby recommendation.

The guide matters more than the itinerary

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - The guide matters more than the itinerary

The route gives you the framework, but the guide shapes the experience. This is clear from the range of praise for Walter, Ariel, Ryan, Arielle, Kate, Emma, Christopher, Kamala, Jack, Jenna, Emily, and others.

Walter has been praised for combining humor with strong historical detail. Ariel is known for energy, charm, and drink recommendations. Ryan has done well with mixed groups from several countries, keeping the evening organized while explaining Prohibition, Hell’s Kitchen, and the Irish mob.

Kate and Emma have also been praised for making the experience friendly and easy for families. Emily brought history into the conversation while helping the group enjoy the cocktails. These comments point to an important strength: the host is not just leading the walk. The host is responsible for the pace, introductions, venue entry, and the tone of the evening.

A good guide also helps the experience work for solo visitors. One person who joined alone found the group social and welcoming. If you are in New York by yourself and want an evening with a built-in plan, this tour can be a practical choice.

Still, a host cannot control every venue. The energy may vary from one stop to the next, and the group may include people with different ideas about what makes a speakeasy interesting.

Is $38 a fair price?

The Secret Speakeasies and History Experience! - Is $38 a fair price?

At $38 per person, the price is reasonable if you plan to visit all three venues and use the express entry. You are paying for a licensed host, the historical commentary, admission, and help navigating popular Midtown bars.

The value is strongest when the guide is engaging and the venues are busy. Walking into a crowded bar instead of waiting outside can save time and make the evening feel more special. You also get a prepared route rather than spending your own night searching for places.

The value is weaker if you judge the tour only by the number of secret rooms. At least one account found the later stops ordinary rather than hidden. If you already know New York’s cocktail scene or prefer to choose your own bars, a self-guided evening may suit you better.

Budget at least another $45 to $60 if you expect to buy three cocktails, before gratuity. Drinks can be more or less than the reported $15 average, and food is extra. Gratuity for the guide is not included either.

Who should book this evening?

I would recommend it to couples, friends, solo visitors, and families with adult children who want a social night with a clear plan. It suits people who like cocktails but also want context about New York neighborhoods, Broadway, and Prohibition.

It is especially useful for a first visit to Midtown. You get a quick orientation to Times Square, Broadway country, rooftop views, and Hell’s Kitchen without committing to a long walking tour.

You should think twice if you do not drink, dislike crowded nightlife, or want a quiet history lesson. The tour is built around bars, and the venues are part of the experience. You can enjoy the stories without ordering much, but you will still spend the evening in drinking-focused spaces.

Dress in upscale casual clothing. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not allowed, so pack accordingly. Wear comfortable shoes, and leave room in your schedule for the three-hour walk and stops.

The booking pattern also suggests planning ahead. It is booked about 33 days in advance on average, so I would not wait until the last minute for a popular travel date. Free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start time. Cancellations or changes inside that window are not refundable, and the tour can also be canceled if too few people book.

Should you book Secret Speakeasies and History?

Book it if you want a guided night of cocktails, local stories, and easy entry to three different Midtown and Hell’s Kitchen venues. The best parts are the varied settings, rooftop view, small group, and hosts who bring real personality to the Prohibition story.

Skip it if you want every stop to be a genuinely secret bar or if you are trying to keep the evening inexpensive. The $38 entry price is fair, but drinks, food, and gratuity can quickly add to the bill.

For most people who enjoy New York nightlife, I would book it for the social setting and the guide rather than the promise of secret doors alone. The history gives the bar hopping a purpose, and the neighborhood route gives you more than a string of cocktails.

FAQ

How much does the experience cost?

The tour costs $38 per person. Food, alcoholic drinks, and gratuity are not included.

How long does the tour last?

The experience lasts approximately three hours.

How many venues will I visit?

You will visit at least three of New York City’s bars, pubs, and speakeasies.

Where does the tour begin?

The meeting point is 825 8th Avenue, New York, New York 10019.

Where does the tour end?

The tour ends in Hell’s Kitchen, New York, New York 10036.

What should I wear?

The dress code is upscale casual. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not permitted.

Can I cancel for a refund?

You can cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not refunded.

More like this

New York City History Tours, compared.

The full New York City History Tours list →
NYC: Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 474 reviews· from $36

NYC: Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour

Read our review →
Hamilton and Washington Revolutionary Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 182 reviews· from $52

Hamilton and Washington Revolutionary Walking Tour

Read our review →
#1 Rated NYC Chinatown Food and History Walking Tour with FNYT
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 171 reviews· from $99

#1 Rated NYC Chinatown Food and History Walking Tour with FNYT

Read our review →
Tribeca Architecture And History Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 141 reviews· from $50

Tribeca Architecture And History Walking Tour

Read our review →
NYC: Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.6· 128 reviews· from $36

NYC: Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour

Read our review →
Christmas in New York: Private Holiday History Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 107 reviews· from $165

Christmas in New York: Private Holiday History Tour

Read our review →
Lower Manhattan Secrets And History Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 96 reviews· from $60

Lower Manhattan Secrets And History Walking Tour

Read our review →
NYC: History of Slavery & Underground Railroad Walking Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 87 reviews· from $49

NYC: History of Slavery & Underground Railroad Walking Tour

Read our review →

Browse the lists this tour appears in

Scroll to Top

Where to take a history tour

Pick a century, a country or a city.