Review · NEW YORK CITY
Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour NYC
Secrets still hide behind Midtown doors. This three-hour walking tour pairs Prohibition-era stories with visits to three cocktail bars around Times Square, the Broadway district, and nearby neighborhoods. I like the small group size, capped at 18 people, and I like that guides such as Ryan, Ariel, Walter, Katherine, and Julian bring plenty of humor and personality to the evening. The main catch is simple: the $38 tour price does not include drinks, and cocktails can cost about $20 each.
You should also set your expectations carefully. One stop may feel like a true speakeasy, with an unobvious entrance and creative drinks. Other venues can feel more like stylish, easy-to-find bars or restaurants than secret Prohibition hideouts. If you want good stories, a social night out, and three different drinking spots, this tour has appeal. If you want three authentic underground bars, the experience may not fully match the name.
Key points before you book

- Three stops, three different moods: Expect a mix of historic-feeling, theatrical, and modern cocktail venues rather than three identical speakeasies.
- The guides are the main attraction: Ryan, Ariel, Walter, Katherine, Julian, Emma, and D have earned strong praise for humor, storytelling, and local recommendations.
- The $38 price covers entry, not drinks: Plan for roughly $20 per cocktail, plus any taxes or gratuity arrangements at the venues.
- The walking is manageable: The route links Midtown areas around Times Square and Broadway, with no report of strenuous walking, but you should still wear comfortable shoes.
- Dress neatly: Upscale casual clothing is required. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not permitted.
- Bring valid identification: You must be at least 21. Non-U.S. citizens need a passport, not simply another form of identification.
What this Midtown night is really about

This experience is less about discovering a single secret bar and more about seeing how New York’s drinking culture has changed over time. The guide connects the Prohibition years with the Gilded Age, local personalities, old entertainment districts, and the streets around Times Square.
That setting matters. Midtown can feel loud, bright, and commercial, but the tour uses the area’s theaters, hotels, restaurants, and nightlife as a backdrop for stories about a less open era. You move through one of New York’s most famous entertainment zones, then pause at bars that offer different takes on the old speakeasy idea.
The tour lasts about three hours. That gives the guide time to tell stories between drinks instead of rushing you from door to door. It also means you should not treat this as a quick pre-theater stop. The evening is meant to be the main activity.
The group limit of 18 is a useful middle ground. You get the social energy of meeting other people without being part of a huge crowd. Solo visitors can easily find company, while couples and friends still have enough room to enjoy the night together.
A few more history tours around New York City worth a look
- NYC: Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour
★ 4.7 · 474 reviews - The Original Greenwich Village Food & Cultural Tour Since 1999
★ 5.0 · 254 reviews - The Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History
★ 5.0 · 220 reviews
Starting at 825 8th Avenue
The meeting point is 825 8th Avenue in Midtown Manhattan. This puts you close to Times Square, Broadway, and several major subway routes, so the starting point is practical if you are already sightseeing in central Manhattan.
The first part of the tour sets the tone. Your guide explains what to expect, introduces the Prohibition theme, and begins walking through the surrounding entertainment district. The route is not presented as a museum visit. It is a moving history lesson, with stories delivered on the street and at the bars.
Guides are important here. Ryan receives especially high praise for his wit, pacing, and storytelling. Ariel is often described as funny and informative, while Walter is praised for entertaining local commentary. Katherine has been appreciated for adding a native New Yorker’s point of view. The individual guide can shape the night, so expect personality rather than a dry lecture.
The first bar is often the strongest match for the classic speakeasy idea. Accounts describe an unobvious door, a password-style entrance, and inventive cocktails. That is the kind of arrival that makes the theme click. You are not simply walking into a bar with a sign over the door. You are taking part in a small piece of theater.
Still, the evening is not built around free samples. You choose and purchase your own food and drinks. If you are not drinking alcohol, the available options and prices should be checked at the venue.
Times Square as part of the story

The walk through Times Square is not just a transfer between bars. It gives you a look at the area’s layers, from the historic Broadway theater district to the modern nightlife that fills the streets today.
Your guide may point out how entertainment, advertising, nightlife, and public crowds shaped this part of Manhattan. The supplied route also places the experience near a well-known nightclub, Broadway, and the area just north of Times Square and south of Central Park. Those broad landmarks help you understand the geography, even if the exact stops change.
This is also where the tour’s atmosphere can shift. Times Square is noisy, crowded, and filled with bright signs. That can make the old stories more vivid, but it can also make it harder to hear. One less favorable experience found the music at the first and final venues too loud for the historical explanations to come through clearly.
I would stay close to the guide and ask questions while walking. If you lose a sentence inside a noisy bar, the next street segment may give you a better chance to catch up.
The second stop: stylish, but not always secret

The middle stop is where expectations matter most. Some participants have found the second venue fun and distinctive, but not especially secret. Lillies is mentioned as a clearly marked restaurant rather than an obscure entrance. That does not make it a poor place to visit, but it does weaken the classic speakeasy illusion.
This is a common issue with modern speakeasy culture. Many bars now borrow passwords, hidden doors, Art Deco decoration, dark lighting, and vintage drink menus. They may capture the mood without having a direct connection to Prohibition-era New York.
You may appreciate the contrast. After a more concealed first stop, a polished restaurant or cocktail venue shows how the speakeasy theme has been repackaged for today. You may also feel that you could have found the place without a guide.
The historical value depends heavily on where the guide speaks. If your main reason for booking is the history, listen carefully during the outdoor portions and ask the guide to repeat anything lost to restaurant noise. If your main reason is trying different bars, this stop is easier to accept.
Same place, a different slice of the past:
- Hamilton and Washington Revolutionary Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 182 reviews - #1 Rated NYC Chinatown Food and History Walking Tour with FNYT
★ 5.0 · 171 reviews - Tribeca Architecture And History Walking Tour
★ 5.0 · 141 reviews - NYC: Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour
★ 4.6 · 128 reviews
The third venue and the final drink

The final stop continues the pattern of variety. Descriptions point to an Art Deco-style bar, a live music venue, or a place with a more modern, polished feel. One account described a dark Broadway theme, while another mentioned a festive music setting. These details suggest that the exact bar lineup may vary, or that different nights can feel quite different.
That variety is one of the tour’s strengths. You are not spending three hours in three copies of the same dim cocktail room. Each venue can offer a different setting, menu, and crowd. Several people particularly liked the fact that they would not have chosen these places on their own.
The weakness is authenticity. One bar may feel convincingly secret, while another may simply be a trendy cocktail bar with a period-inspired design. A final venue may have good food and atmosphere but little direct connection to Prohibition.
Drink quality can also vary. Most feedback is positive, with cocktails described as strong, creative, or enjoyable. One account found the drinks at the final stop disappointing but liked the food. I would treat the bar choices as part of the experience, not as a guarantee that every cocktail will suit your taste.
The guides make or break the evening

The strongest praise centers on the people leading the tour. Ryan is repeatedly described as funny, energetic, and well prepared. His storytelling is said to hold attention from the opening explanation through the final stop. Ariel receives similar praise for humor and historical detail. Walter is described as an entertaining source of local information, and Katherine is valued for her flexibility and personal connection to New York.
This matters because the bar interiors alone are not enough to fill three hours. A good guide ties each place back to the wider story of Prohibition, New York nightlife, famous personalities, and changing social customs.
The guide also manages the practical side of the night. One account praised a host for adjusting plans to changing conditions and offering useful recommendations. Another noted that the guide knew staff members at each venue, which helped the group feel more welcome.
Not every experience is guaranteed to feel equally polished. One account found the guide less engaged, while another felt that loud music reduced the amount of history they could hear. That is a fair warning: your enjoyment will depend partly on the guide assigned to your departure and the noise level at the venues.
What the $38 price really buys you

At $38 per person, the tour fee is reasonable for a three-hour guided evening in Midtown. It includes the guide, walking tour, admission to three venues, and preferred entry. For a first visit to New York, that can be useful. You do not have to research three bars, work out the route, or guess which doors are worth trying.
The final bill is more important than the advertised tour price. Drinks are not included, and a cocktail may cost around $20. If you buy one at each stop, you could spend about $60 per person before considering food, tax, and gratuity.
The handling of gratuity deserves attention. The tour information says gratuity is not included. At least one account says the guide collected the bill at each stop with taxes and tips included, and the operator explained that gratuity is automatically applied to groups in New York City. Policies can be confusing, so ask your guide what is included before ordering.
For two people, three cocktails each can make the evening much more expensive than the $76 tour fees suggest. If you want to control spending, order fewer drinks, share food, or decide in advance how much you want to spend at each venue.
The value is best if you see the fee as payment for access, planning, storytelling, and company. It is less compelling if you only want three drinks in three bars, since you could arrange that yourself.
Dress, age, walking, and timing
You must be at least 21 years old and carry valid photo identification. Non-U.S. citizens are specifically asked to bring a passport. Do not leave identification at the hotel.
The dress code is upscale casual. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not allowed. You do not need formal evening clothes, but neat trousers, a clean shirt, a dress, or similar attire is the safer choice.
The walking is moderate. The route moves through Midtown, Times Square, Broadway, and nearby areas, but the experience is not described as physically demanding. Wear shoes you can manage for several hours, especially if the weather is cold or wet.
Several start times are available, which helps you fit the tour around a day of sightseeing. The ending point is in Times Square, so you remain in a useful part of Manhattan for dinner, another drink, or a subway ride.
The activity is offered in English. Confirmation arrives when you book, and it is close to public transportation. Free cancellation is available if you cancel at least 24 hours before the start time. Changes or cancellations inside that window are not accepted, and the minimum group requirement can affect whether a departure operates.
Who should book this experience
I would recommend this tour to you if you want a social evening with a guide, enjoy cocktail bars, and like learning history in small pieces while walking through the city. It works well for couples, friends, solo visitors, and families with adult children who meet the age requirement.
Solo visitors may find the group especially useful. The format gives you conversation, a ready-made route, and an easy way to spend an evening without planning every stop yourself.
You should be cautious if your main goal is historical accuracy at every venue. The first stop may deliver the strongest speakeasy atmosphere, while the later bars can feel more modern, public, or theatrical. You should also be cautious if you are trying to keep the night inexpensive. The drinks add up quickly.
Should you book the Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour?
Book it if you want an entertaining Midtown walk led by a lively guide, with three different cocktail stops and plenty of New York atmosphere. The strongest part is the combination of storytelling, local nightlife, and access to places you might not pick on your own.
Skip it if you expect three genuine, secret Prohibition bars or if the $20-per-drink range will make the evening stressful. Go in expecting a guided cocktail crawl with historical storytelling, not a pure history tour. With that framing, the $38 entry price can be fair value, especially when you get a guide like Ryan, Ariel, Walter, Katherine, or Julian.
FAQ
How long does the tour last?
The experience lasts approximately three hours.
How much does the tour cost?
The listed tour price is $38 per person.
Are drinks included?
No. Drinks and food are available for purchase at each venue. Cocktail prices have been reported at around $20 per drink.
How many bars do you visit?
The tour includes three speakeasies or cocktail venues, ranging from modern locations to more historic-feeling bars.
Where does the tour start and end?
It starts at 825 8th Avenue in New York City and ends in Times Square, Manhattan.
Is the tour suitable for anyone under 21?
No. The minimum age is 21, and you need valid photo identification. Non-U.S. citizens need a passport.
What should I wear?
The dress code is upscale casual. Sportswear and ripped clothing are not permitted.
Can I cancel for a refund?
Yes. You can cancel at least 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Cancellations or changes made less than 24 hours before the start time are not accepted or refunded.
Just added around New York City
- Wall Street Inside with a Trader Walking History Tour★ 5.0 · 23 reviews
- The Psychiatric History of New York: Upper East Side Tour★ 5.0 · 31 reviews
- The Original Greenwich Village Food & Cultural Tour Since 1999★ 5.0 · 254 reviews
- Tenement History and Immigrant Life in the Lower East Side★ 5.0 · 50 reviews
- New York City: Mafia History in Little Italy Walking Tour w/NYPD★ 5.0 · 59 reviews
- Soul of Harlem: Striver’s Row, Apollo Theatre & Gospel Heritage★ 5.0 · 75 reviews
- The Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History★ 5.0 · 220 reviews
- Private Tour New York City in the Gilded Age: A History of High Society★ 5.0 · 125 reviews
New York City History Tours, compared.

NYC: Speakeasy Drinks and Prohibition History Tour
Read our review →
The Original Greenwich Village Food & Cultural Tour Since 1999
Read our review →
The Speakeasy Adventure: A Tipsy Trip Through History
Read our review →
Hamilton and Washington Revolutionary Walking Tour
Read our review →
#1 Rated NYC Chinatown Food and History Walking Tour with FNYT
Read our review →
NYC: Night Out Prohibition History Bar and Speakeasy Tour
Read our review →
Private Tour New York City in the Gilded Age: A History of High Society
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in

